Same guy he didn't want. Phil got it right even though we thought he was nuts.

They just need like two more guys better than Melo and they could be a title team.

I'm sure his Hall of Fame speech will contain an apology for Raymond Felton, Amare Stoudamire, and Pablo Prigioni. I'm sure the world will forever hold him responsible for not winning a championship with these All Stars.

I'm sure his Hall of Fame speech will contain an apology for Raymond Felton, Amare Stoudamire, and Pablo Prigioni. I'm sure the world will forever hold him responsible for not winning a championship with these All Stars.

Not over yet.

He actually was traded to the Knicks.

He is a bum. He doesn't care about winning. He has never taken himself to that next level. He is a scorer. Not a star.

Not over yet.

For all the talk the losingness of Carmelo Anthony, his purpose for leaving Denver was to win.

The guy has been on multiple all star teams. He has also been on several Olympic teams. If your assertion is correct then how has that happened?

Goff is the Score's resident NBA Expert and Bulls Insider.

That's all you need to know.

I'm glad that you brought up Brick because he is the ringleader of the absolute argument. It's championship or bust with him until it's not of course. I have exposed the hypocrisy that's all.

Goff's point was that if you get him the ball the Knicks are a better team. This point was made during a time when a lot of people were saying that the ball needed to be in the hands of Jeremy Lin and not Carmelo Anthony. This is great example of revisionist history. He never said that the Knicks would win a championship by simply getting him the ball.

The bolded section is why his point was bad. The Knicks aren't a championship contender with "Just Get The Ball To Anthony". Why not try something different? It may work, but we know what doesn't work and that is what Goff was screaming for the Knicks to do.

They had the easiest schedule in the league at the time. As soon as Lin had to match up with better guards he got tattoed. It is no accident that the new coach has taken the ball out of his hands, not excepted his turnover tendencies (as D'Antoni did) and they are winning. They are also beating better teams during this stretch Philadelphia, Atlanta than what occurred during the whole Linsanity craze yet there are people still bashing Carmelo Anthony. It was stupid to hand the ball over to a guy that glorified D-League call up. A lot of guys have had there exceptional nights against Jeremy Lin but it was Carmelo Anthony that got criticized for not playing defense. Check the numbers

Carmelo has taken a bum rap for the Knicks struggles and conversely Lin has received too much of the credit. The Knick resurgence under Lin occurred during a period in which they had the easiest schedule in the league (check the schedule) As soon as the schedule and level of point guard improved Lin was exposed. Carmelo Anthony is taking heat because of last year's decision regarding impending free agency. At least he allowed Denver an opportunity to receive something in exchange for exiting the team. Everyone is quick to jump on the doesn't make the team better garbage but does anyone remember what Denver was prior to him joining the team. Is anyone paying attention to what Denver is now. The Knick have not drastically improved under him but it is too early to throw the towel in on them. As it was way too early for D'Antoni to hand the team over to a b-rate guard one step removed from the D-League. It's funny how Woodson has figured out the error of D'Antoni's ways and the Knicks are playing better ball with Anthony leading the way. The Anthony detractors however are still holding to the fallacious consensus that he is hurting the team

You were wrong. Get over it.