There are major questions about Luck after this year. I was a strong believer but you have to wonder if he just isn't going to ever get there.

What is the statistic or statistics that determine success of a QB? We seem to differ on that. Without an accord, there can be no bet.

There are major questions about Luck after this year. I was a strong believer but you have to wonder if he just isn't going to ever get there.

I consider QBR, DYAR, and DVOA to be significantly better than QB rating, but I'm willing to make the wager based on QB rating as well. I think Luck is so superior to Dalton and Stafford that he is basically going to outperform them by every metric available. Call it $100?

We have until next August to work this out. I'll get back to you. If we were talking about career rating or rating over the course of a period of time, the bet would be easy for me. But within a season, a lot can happen. Stafford next year may not have receivers to throw to, so it would likely be Dalton vs Luck.

Dont chalk it up to injury this year?

Before this year he was progressing nicely
Passer Rating
76
87
95

Dont chalk it up to injury this year?

Before this year he was progressing nicely
Passer Rating
76
87
95

Except everyone that has watched NFL football and isn't stuck in their 2012 belief that Andrew Luck is the next Marino.

Luck will be a top 10 QB in the NFL for the next 10 years.

Luck is in a pretty similar position when the bears got cutler.

Luck is in a pretty similar position when the bears got cutler.

Luck is much better, he's been hit more than any other QB in the NFL since he's been in the league..and that's including the games he's missed..his line and run game are pretty lousy.

You might want to review news clips of Cutler in Denver. You just make up your mind about shit and spout.

I was pissed the day Cutler trade was announced, I thought he was nothing special in Denver..Dan McNeil was the only voice of reason that day on the Score... Lemme know when that bitch Cutty throws 40 TDs and 16 picks in a season..

Let me know when media darling Luck ever does it again.

I have not got a chance to watch Luck yet this year.

But he definitely seems like a disappointment from what he was built up to be.

Andrew Luck has injury setback, Colts won't promise that he'll return in 2017


Exactly two weeks after returning to practice, Colts quarterback Andrew Luck has hit a giant setback in his rehab.
Colts general manager Chris Ballard announced on Wednesday that Luck is dealing with some shoulder soreness that's been so painful the quarterback had to be given a cortisone shot. The soreness will keep Luck out of practice for the rest of the week, and possibly longer.
According to Ballard, Luck's recovery was coming along as scheduled before this week's complication.
"In terms of rehab, it's going well," Ballard said, via the team's official website. "You've seen him throw, I've watched every session of him throwing and it's been going really well: His velocity is good, his motion is good, all that is coming along at a good rate. It's the soreness right now that we're dealing with and that we have to get through."
After the soreness hit, the team decided that shutting Luck down for the immediate future was the best long-term move for the organization.
"We're going to try to shut him down and calm it down for right now," Ballard said. "His long term success is what we're looking for. Much like with any player, that's what's important to us."
One question Ballard refused to answer was whether or not Luck would actually end up playing this season. Although the Colts still have 10 games to play over the next two and a half months, Ballard ducked the question when asked if Luck would be back on the field this year.
"I don't want to speculate right now," Ballard said. "I'm not going to put a timeline on that."
Ballard did add that the team currently has no plans to place Luck on injured reserve, which would end his season.
Luck was asked by NFL.com on Monday if he might be able to play by November, and all he would say is that there's no timetable for his return. Although Luck has been practicing with the Colts off and on since Oct. 4, he's come nowhere close to being game ready.
The Colts quarterback hasn't played in a game since December 2016, and it's slowly starting to look like we might not see him on the field again until the 2018 season. The setback in Luck's recovery this week came almost exactly 10 months after he originally underwent shoulder surgery in January.
With Luck out indefinitely, that means the Colts will move forward with Jacoby Brissett as their starting quarterback. The former Patriots backup quarterback has started five games for Indy since being acquired in a September trade that sent Phillip Dorsett to New England.