But this isn’t a meatball argument. If you compare their age 24 seasons it’s clear who the better player was. Maybe I don’t value defense enough but Moncada was clearly a FAR SUPERIOR offensive player last year. He’s 3 years younger. He’s seemingly getting better. Baez is seemingly not.

It stands to reason Moncada would be the better player next year.

You’d be hard pressed to find a Sox fan poster here who’s been more critical of the team recently so try again.

I’ve explained my reasoning behind thinking Yoan is better. This a dumb thread for you to try this nonsense.

Moncada was far superior to Baez?
Dude. He had one good year. Slow down. For gods sake. You sound like jorr suckin on Palkas pecker.

Yeah your poll is really showing it too.

Read better

Lol. Have fun with the “what’s popular is right” argument.

Luckily we can revisit this.

Ok. Resorting to the you're dumb argument. Do you really believe that I'm dumb or I don't read well?

I don’t believe you read that post well or if you did you’re being intentionally dishonest. Which is it?

Now if you want to quote what I actually said we can continue.

Baez hasn’t been consistent at all. He’s a wildly inconsistent player. Moncada, like I said, was the far superior offensive player, he’s 3 years younger, he looked great at 3rd this past year and he has the prospect pedigree and has displayed all the potential and tools to suggest he’s going to continue being great. It looks like a solid bet he’s going to be better than Baez offensively again and considering everything else it also seems like a solid bet he will be better overall and continue to be.

That’s the beauty of this type of medium. We can revisit this and I’m sure we will.

But the exhausting shit was nonsense and you know it. Don’t have the arrogance to think you’re going to tell other posters who have been here over a dozen years how to post.

Baez hasn’t been consistent at all. He’s a wildly inconsistent player. Moncada, like I said, was the far superior offensive player, he’s 3 years younger, he looked great at 3rd this past year and he has the prospect pedigree and has displayed all the potential and tools to suggest he’s going to continue being great. It looks like a solid bet he’s going to be better than Baez offensively again and considering everything else it also seems like a solid bet he will be better overall and continue to be.

That’s the beauty of this type of medium. We can revisit this and I’m sure we will.

But the exhausting shit was nonsense and you know it. Don’t have the arrogance to think you’re going to tell other posters who have been here over a dozen years how to post.

What is this silly trend so many have of accusing people of telling others how to post? No one told you how to post.

Oh and his stats for the last three years have been far from wildly inconsistent.

If you keep saying dumb thing then you can’t keep asking me if I think you’re dumb.

It’s implied with saying my meatballism is exhausting while wrongly saying I boot lick for the Sox too much.

Oh ok.

OPS of

.796
.881
.847

Very consistent. My fault.

That's that terribly inconsistent. And you cherry picked the most varied stat.
OBP 317 326 316.

For validation?

You really are an idiot.

It's Moncada, right?

Oh.




Yeah. Not the words of a guy looking for validation.

That’s not the pro-Baez argument you think it is.

Selectively quoting. Like I said, you’re either dumb or dishonest, your choice amigo. I can see both.

Selective quoting? It was your first post! You posted this poll for validation.

Selectively quoting. Yes, that’s what you did. By purposely omitting the reason I started the poll. That would be a dumb thing to lie about. This question really didn’t matter that much to me but I thought most folks would be sensible and say Moncada. We’ll see how this looks a year from now.

I’ll go with intentionally dishonest since I know you know what selectively quoted means in the context of this exchange.

You seem confused which isn’t unusual for you.

My coworker sits by me and knows about this site. It got brought up in conversation and I thought Moncada was of course the better player going forward. He disagreed and said he thinks most folks would say Baez and told me to ask on here. I did. I thought despite the larger number of Cub fans in here Moncada would easily win. I was wrong on that. I underestimated the amount of cub fans who would respond like denis did right away.

I’m quite confident Moncada will be better next year and like I said, the great part of this medium is how easy it will be to look back on this.

The only dishonest person in this thread has been you, who twice has tried to quote me without the full quote to assert a point that was clearly ridiculous. It’s a pattern with you going back awhile now so I’m not saying I’m surprised.

After I said you were an idiot I concluded you’re dishonest instead and I illustrated how and this last post of yours is just more evidence of it.

You seem confused which isn’t unusual for you.

My coworker sits by me and knows about this site. It got brought up in conversation and I thought Moncada was of course the better player going forward. He disagreed and said he thinks most folks would say Baez and told me to ask on here. I did. I thought despite the larger number of Cub fans in here Moncada would easily win. I was wrong on that. I underestimated the amount of cub fans who would respond like denis did right away.

I’m quite confident Moncada will be better next year and like I said, the great part of this medium is how easy it will be to look back on this.

The only dishonest person in this thread has been you, who twice has tried to quote me without the full quote to assert a point that was clearly ridiculous. It’s a pattern with you going back awhile now so I’m not saying I’m surprised.

Oh look, Juiced appears to drop his dumbassness into another Sox thread.

Like a moth to a flame.